NEON
in ,

Sunday Scaries: Maika Monroe is Horror’s Most Underrated Actress

The Sunday Scaries are upon us once again! Yes, as the weekend concludes, most of us feel an oncoming sense of anticipatory dread about the week ahead. Anxiety about work manifests itself into a feeling that’s known as the Sunday Scaries. However, we at Awards Radar are here to combat that, by taking back the name. Now, we want you think about a horror-centric piece on the site when you hear the term. So, let us continue on with another installment of the Awards Radar Sunday Scaries! Today, we’re looking at one of horror’s most underrated assets…

Bleecker Street

Maika Monroe is the most underrated actress in horror. She first broke through for me with It Follows, really impressing in a quiet yet powerful role (coming right alongside work in The Guest that suggested big things to come). Then, a few years ago, after some interesting work in things like Watcher, for example, she blew me away with Longlegs, a modern horror classic (you can hear my chat with her and filmmaker Osgood Perkins here, as well as a different chat with just her about a different movie here). This weekend, Monroe stars in Victorian Psycho, her latest foray into the genre. That got me thinking about how much I love her work in fright flicks and how, while horror loves to generate the next “it girl” a lot, a la Inde Navarrette here in 2026, Monroe has been a steady force for over a decade now.

My review here of Victorian Psycho back at the start of the week praised her like so:

Maika Monroe gets to really let loose here, especially as things progress. Initially, you get a kick out of watching her try to keep the psycho aspect of her personality in check. However, as that becomes less and less possible, Monroe gets to go all in on some big choices. It’s an incredibly enjoyable turn from her.

NEON

Previously, I raved about her within my raves of Longlegs multiple times in 2024, including here in my initial four star review:

Maika Monroe and Nicolas Cage are both outstanding here. Monroe is one of the most compelling and interesting heroines since Clarice Starling, while Cage’s title character will haunt your nightmares. The former never loses the fear and human touch of this new agent, even if she’s no-nonsense, gifted at her job, and a force of nature. When she’s scared, we’re scared. It’s the best performance to date from Monroe, who first blew me away with It Follows.

A24

I’ve obviously also talked about It Follows previously and my hopes for They Follow. The latter especially should cement her as one of horror’s gems, but I already feel like she’s become a secret weapon for filmmakers. Monroe is easily one of horror’s most underrated actresses, as she’s far more than just a scream queen. She can anchor a scary movie and lead from any number of avenues. That makes her a horror force to be reckoned with.

Maika Monroe should be a name synonymous with horror, and if it’s not already, that should change by next year with They Follow. If and when that happens, I’ll be back to update this piece. For now, this can just be an ode to Monroe’s talents and elevation of work within the genre. Here’s hoping it’s still just the beginning for her…

Stay tuned for another Sunday Scaries installment next week!

Comments

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments

Loading…

0

Written by Joey Magidson

‘Fatherland’ and ‘La bola negra’ Lead the 2027 European Film Award Nominations

Awards Radar Community: Who Do You Want to See Cast as the New James Bond?