John Madden is a legend of football, three times over. First, there was his coaching career, which came in the aftermath of an injury ending his playing career. Then, there was his broadcasting career, for which more people would ultimately know him for. Finally, there’s his namesake video game franchise, which arguably will be his lasting legacy. All this to say, a movie about the man has a lot of avenues with which it can explore him. Unfortunately, the David O. Russell film Madden wants to go down all these roads, limiting its effectiveness in the process.
Madden doesn’t set itself up for success with the stunt casting of Nicolas Cage in the title role. Now, to be fair, Cage is hardly the problem here (more on him later), but burying him in makeup and prosthetics just to appear like Madden is distracting. The flick never turns into the Saturday Night Live sketch that it could have devolved into, luckily, but in rushing to cover decades in the man’s life, very little ends up feeling impactful.
This is a biopic about John Madden (Cage), who we meet as the coach of the Oakland Raiders, working with his best friend and the team’s owner, Al Davis (Christian Bale). He’s a winner in the regular season, but can’t quite make the Super Bowl. Then, in 1977 it finally happens. John gets the Raiders over the hump and they’re champions. The deal was that then he’d spend more time with his wife Virginia (Kathryn Hahn) and their two sons, but to Al, the win just means doubling down in order to win more. This takes a toll on John, leading to a diagnosis of a bleeding ulcer, and then immediate retirement from coaching.
The retired life does not fit John, quickly putting him, alongside his family, at wit’s end. Al wants him back on the sideline, while Virginia wants him out of the house. The latter helps to arrange for him to become a sports commentator, where his unique insight and musings would prove iconic. That alone would be enough to cement him in sports history, but it’s when he gets involved with Electronic Arts founder Trip Hawkins (John Mulaney) that he’d become a pioneer. Together, they would end up creating Madden NFL Football, one of the most groundbreaking video games of all time. Through it all, his friendship with Al has peaks and valleys, as both bring out the best and worst in each other.

The highlight here is the chemistry between Christian Bale and Nicolas Cage. Both characters are played fairly broadway, so these two intense actors are fully committed, leading to some very amusing scenes. Bale plays Al Davis as a real fast talker and hustler, but someone who believes in what he expounds on, especially the Raiders’ patented “commitment to excellence.” There’s a good heart buried within the ridiculousness, which Bale recognizes. Cage is most at home as John Madden during the third act, and looks most like him late in the game, but resists the urge to make this a cartoonish portrayal. The screenplay doesn’t give him much nuance, but he’s having fun and still getting to actually act here. Kathryn Hahn gets some good lines, though it does feel like her role is often superfluous or cut down, especially whenever potential conflict in the marriage comes up. In addition to an amusing but underserved John Mulaney, supporting players here include Shane Gillis, Joel Murray, and Sienna Miller, to name a few, but Bale and Cage are the notable performances.
Co-writer/director David O. Russell, working with co-writer Cambron Clark, sees his trademark chaos on screen not hit like it once did. Visually, there are some stylish tricks used, and things don’t look bad, but you’d be shocked to realize that the cinematography is by Robert Richardson. Russell’s direction just doesn’t land like it used to. Here, it does seem like the script he wrote with Clark never figures out where to focus. Is this about John Madden the football coach? The broadcaster? The man? I’m unclear if they know the answer. In trying to do it all, it limits the effectiveness. The character is the most enjoyable during the video game section, but by then, you’ve sat through too much to not have somewhat checked out. Clark and Russell should have leaned more into the friendship between Davis and Madden, not just because Bale and Cage have strong chemistry, but because that’s the only emotional resonance in the film.
Madden would have succeeded with a tighter focus. Russell’s quirkiness no longer seems to work, so his contribution seems like a distraction, as opposed to a benefit. What could have been a look at two football lifers and their friendship ends up being only maybe a quarter about that, to the movie’s detriment. In football parlance, Madden puts together a few good drives, but the offense consistently stalls out in the red zone.
SCORE: ★★1/2




Comments
Loading…